Housing news & rental opportunities
New-home sales picked up. Put new builds on your rental comparison list.
The September 24 housing report offers a useful reason to compare a finished new home with a resale rental—using local rents, full costs and the same financing assumptions.
Pillar Private Lending · · 3 min read
A fresh housing headline, with an important limit
On September 24, the U.S. Census Bureau and HUD estimated August new single-family home sales at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 684,000, up 6.4% from July. That is an annualized pace, not the number of homes sold during August. The reported margin of error for the monthly change was plus or minus 19.5 percentage points, so the estimate does not establish a clear monthly increase.
For rental investors and their agents, the release is a useful prompt to widen the comparison list. A finished new home may deserve a look alongside a resale property. The national report does not measure local rental demand or prove that either choice is a bargain. Start your application with a specific property, or check loan options while you compare.
Compare two homes that serve the same renter
Choose a finished new build and a resale home with reasonably similar locations, bedroom counts and intended tenant appeal. Ask your agent or property manager for current local rent evidence. Keep asking rents separate from signed leases, and note any concessions or differences in condition. A higher purchase price does not automatically support higher rent.
For each property, list the purchase price, immediate work, estimated closing costs and cash remaining afterward. Then compare the recurring picture: supported rent, financing payments, taxes, insurance, association dues where applicable, maintenance and vacancy. Use property-specific estimates; a new home still needs an operating budget.
Look beyond the advertised incentive
If a builder offers a price adjustment, closing credit or financing promotion, ask for the terms in writing. Check whether an investor purchase qualifies, whether using a particular lender is required, and how the offer changes the total transaction. Do not put an advertised incentive into your base case until its applicability is confirmed.
Use the same comparison method for the resale home. A repair allowance is different from completed work, and a lower price may come with an earlier cash outlay for improvements. The useful question is which complete plan fits your cash and timeline, rather than which listing has the most eye-catching offer.
Make the financing conversation property-specific
Pillar offers DSCR rental financing. Bring the two property scenarios to the discussion and ask which financing paths fit each home in its current condition. A finished rental purchase and a property needing substantial work may call for different planning. Do not assume a future refinance will solve a purchase that cannot support its current costs.
Keep the lender discussion and your investment budget connected but distinct. Ask what income and payment figures the proposed financing review uses, while maintaining your own full expense plan. For referral partners, this is a concrete way to reconnect with a client: offer to compare one new-build option and one resale option using supported local numbers.
Turn the comparison into a next step
Pick the property you want to explore, then gather its address, price, condition, rent support and intended closing timeline. Mark the figures that still need confirmation. You do not need to predict the next national housing report to have a productive financing conversation.
Start your application to bring that opportunity to Pillar, or check loan options if you are still narrowing the list. A broader search can uncover another candidate; the property details and complete numbers decide whether it belongs in your plan.
Share this article
Copy HTML code creates an email teaser with this article’s image and link. Paste into your email platform’s HTML editor and keep its mailing address and unsubscribe footer.
Explore financing for this strategy
General educational information. Illustrations are not loan offers or commitments. Financing is subject to property and borrower review, program availability, and applicable terms.